---
title: "Tim Scott I'm not redefining anything.  I just don't agree that..."
date: 2025-10-13
source: facebook
type: comment
context: "Archer T. Ships replied to Oshan Anand's comment."
fb_link: "https://www.facebook.com/dyi/l/?l=AYP87ELz2KIFoyt_1kqdu7c53LkrVH39yTIXQn7yVtyU8NBxIAGOty0ANsXz3jCCB1HC1OeCoE434tZ4Nrvg17cQrl4Y0ak_8FPez8APaaO729xuqaV9WrFInhz9QL0YCAaSp_w43-FT5Ek_eDjA3mfpHHrmXnamTGQd88pOP9lih-4MXjyEWAG2mTE-gg4QzyXRrPCbJdGt&s=519"
---

# Tim Scott I'm not redefining anything.  I just don't agree that...

*October 13, 2025 — Comment Archer T. Ships replied to Oshan Anand's comment.*

Tim Scott I'm not redefining anything.  I just don't agree that forced collectivization is a defining characteristic of socialists.  Just as I don't think being pro-choice or pro-open borders is a defining trait of libertarians.  Even though I think that both positions are more consistent with libertarian principles.