---
title: "Philip Do you think that the US would have been poorer if we had..."
date: 2025-10-28
source: facebook
type: comment
context: "Archer T. Ships replied to Philip Greenspun's comment."
fb_link: "https://www.facebook.com/dyi/l/?l=AYPpyp7ZJG1-RRt5lEnAh5guR5Mb6Bd1VnqaokG8uEMPEacwGhcfXoYdZShzhZVAF1CP9G6C1QEDqH5r13q9CcoNHHGJV7dOMZWnuA2brBdXtkp0FRbTOBF7wH-HWCC5wvaljyR4b6WL30cWQEi1oVjzg-DmEOLVzJCSTzzxxjaSZZ_kZzZq0YxJJidflvReFaie2cy-V_cv&s=519"
---

# Philip Do you think that the US would have been poorer if we had...

*October 28, 2025 — Comment Archer T. Ships replied to Philip Greenspun's comment.*

Philip Do you think that the US would have been poorer if we had accepted Jewish immigrants during WWII?  Would we be richer if you were deported back to Europe?  After all, as a statistical class, rich Jews like you overwhelmingly support socialist /progressive policies and the Democratic party.